Bojack has definitely returned to his scandal sheet since having the premise flatly debunked, yet the original and flatly inaccurate headline remains unchanged. His entire response has been to post two additional comments that essentially attempt to call Williams' story into question. He worries that other meetings were held that are not listed on the report. Uh, maybe he didn't attend those meetings? And as I indicate below, Williams' attempt at excess disclosure is turned by Bojack into something just as 'suspicious' as if he'd not disclosed at all...
-------------
Since last week, when a new and much more City-favorable agreement was reached with Merritt Paulson on the remodeling of PGE Park for an MLS Portland Timbers franchise, I've been figuring on professional Drudge-accurate curmudgeon Jack Bogdanski either shutting up for good on the subject, or going into hyperdrive to keep his festering opposition going.
Can you guess which he picked? Undaunted by news that the primary sticking point of "taxpayer funding" has been largely eliminated due to the tabling of urban renewal dollars, that Paulson is now agreeing to pay 2/3 of the estimated costs, and the City's administrative honcho says there's plenty of money in the Spectator Fund to cover the rest even if ticket sales don't pan out, Bojack continues to try and find angles for his opposition.
His complaints on the deal from the day the agreement was announced (I'm not going to link to any of it except the specific story I'll reference in a moment) were that it was foisted on Council with only 10 minutes of lead time (uh, plus the two weeks they're taking before voting on it), and the possibility that Paulson will ask for more money later (rather than celebrating the $6mil reduction in overall costs for the new plan).
Oh, but that was just for starters! Subsequently, Bojack fed the home-team trolls at his site with stories on:
"Uncomfortable" stands (despite apparently being an inch wider than standard)
Poor soccer attendance...for a Timbers AWAY game
Rain for the AAA All-Star activities at PGE, as a way of lamenting the jettisoning of the Beavers from current plans
The fact that Paulson doesn't routinely open the books of his private holding company to the City
and the City of Petaluma failing to reach a deal with Paulson in 2006 for a single-A franchise.
Today's hit piece, however, represents the apex of drive-by blogging--using his frequent source of "an alert reader" to attack his target. Maybe Jack would do well to vet some of those reader comments before he publishes under a blustery headline like OHSU is Involved in Paulson Stadiums Deal:
When Portlanders get a strong hit of that real estate development scam smell, a number of suspects immediately come to mind. But who would have thought that Oregon Health and Sciences University had an interest in the Paulson soccer-baseball empire?
An alert reader points us to this document-- a disclosure of lobbyist contacts with Portland city officials for the first three months of the year. And there we find that OHSU had someone named Mark Williams have no fewer than five personal meetings with Fireman Randy to discuss "soccer/baseball." In 31 years in Portland, we thought we'd seen everything, but the explanation for this one ought to be a doozy. Williams heads OHSU's planning, development and real estate unit. How is that connected with the Paulson deal?
A new deal focusing on just the acquistion and siting of the Portland MLS franchise has been hammered out between City Council and Merritt Paulson, the potential franchisee who was staring down a league-imposed deadline for a deal to keep his bid. The accelerated pace that only recently Mayor Adams had apparently admitted would not meet the league's timeline, combined with the simpler and leaner needs sans Beavers and a put-up-or-shut-up attitude from 3/5 of Council, may have driven Paulson to accept a much higher level of personal risk: roughly 2/3 of the total cost--with a stable funding stream to repay the City for the other third. More on my understanding of the details below the fold, but right now here's KATU's decent piece on passage:
As we know, no one is working harder or more frenetically to gin up opposition to the deal bringing MLS to Portland than Jack Bogdanski at his Crucible of Curmudgeonry, bojack.org. Grasping at any potential straw to indicate an agreement falling apart or suffering from lost support, bojack presents this article from Willy Week as his proof that "the wheels are coming off," asserting that "3rd vote" commissioner Dan Saltzman "smells a rat" and is now reconsidering his support.
To be fair, although WWeek's headline is somewhat more accurate and they may well have been misled a bit by what they print as Saltzman's comments, in the paper's recurring role as Bojack Lite on this issue they make rather the same mistake:
Saltzman, of course, was the swing vote on the council March 11, when this deal won initial approval. His proposed (and until now, unreported) amendment sheds new light on Adams’ announcement Monday that he would postpone three key votes on the soccer-baseball deal and reconsider the best use of Memorial Coliseum. At the time it appeared Adams was bowing to public opinion that called for saving Memorial Coliseum. Now it appears the mayor may have thought he was on the verge of losing his third vote.
Last night, Saltzman says he came to the conclusion that the proposed Rose Quarter redevelopment scheme calling for a new baseball stadium and an entertainment district south of Broadway is still moving too fast, despite a second one-week delay on finalizing the deal.
Citing lack of process, his own nostalgia for Memorial Coliseum (and a long-ago Jethro Tull concert) and increasingly troublesome questions about the deal’s financing, Saltzman says he told the mayor he wants to decouple the Major League Soccer deal from the Rose Quarter redevelopment.
Wouldn’t that imply Saltzman opposes the pre-development agreement, since it ties construction of a new baseball stadium to the city’s deal with Paulson to bring MLS to Portland?
“Yeah,” Saltzman told WW. “I didn’t say it [to Adams] in those black-and-white terms. I’m still going to listen to what he has to say about what he may come back with, but that’s the way I’m feeling now.”
Note carefully what Saltzman is saying (his quote notwithstanding)--not that he doesn't support bringing MLS to Portland under the terms Paulson specified, but that the baseball park doesn't HAVE to go in the Rose Quarter, and that the rest of the entertainment district and how the Coliseum fits into that should be a separate discussion from renovating PGE Park and bringing the Timbers here...because of course MLS doesn't care whether the Beavers have a place to play or not, as long as it's not PGE Park.
I wouldn't share Saltzman's perspective on this necessarily, but it's a rational point to make. It apparently was so rational that Mayor Adams and Merritt Paulson seemingly agree, as today's Oregonian reports.
They have indefinitely delayed the baseball siting question, essentially decoupling it from the rest of the deal, which is what Saltzman wanted. And much more directly, we have confirmation that he is still behind that part:
Commissioner Dan Saltzman said he wouldn't vote to raze the coliseum without a more lengthy public process, one that lasts two or three months and takes a hard look at alternatives.
"If I'm going to make a decision to demolish the coliseum, I'd like to do that knowing there's been some process to look at the options," he said. "All these competing uses in the Rose Quarter and the implicit commitment of public money makes me think we ought to slow it down."
Saltzman said he's not opposed to ultimately tearing down the coliseum, a building he's nostalgic about, but he wants to make sure it's the right move. He also said he's still in favor of bringing Major League Soccer to Portland and is still behind the city's agreement with Paulson. [emph mine]
So what's the upshot here? Are the wheels really falling off, or is Council doing almost exactly what critics have been asking it to do about the Coliseum issue--slow down? Saltzman still supports the deal, but doesn't want to rush the baseball aspect of it into a much larger plan being developed in the Rose Quarter. Couldn't we agree these are good things? (Nahhh, probably not).
As I mentioned in an aside a couple of days ago, I got the opportunity to chat with MLS to PDX spokesman Jeremy Wright last Thursday, in the shadow of PGE Park--where the newly granted Timbers Major League Soccer franchise will begin play in 2011.
Jeremy was an entertaining interview, and gave ample, spot-on responses to my questions. For a little look behind the scenes at the effort to get Major League Soccer to Soccer City USA. The interview lasts about 28 minutes, complete with bypassing skateboarders, Trimet buses, and panhandlers.
The audio file is attached here; you can listen to the entire interview in full that way. Careful; it's a .wma file that's around 14MB large. If you prefer a more readable text version, with quotations smoothed out a little to lose the "ums," "uhhhs" and false starts of sentences, simply keep reading!
-------------- How did you get involved as the tip of the spear for the grassroots effort to bring MLS to PDX, and what specifically have you done in that time to bring MLS here?
In short, I had the time. My background is actually with the Portland Timbers Army. I've been a fan since 2001 when the Timbers came back to town and were playing here at PGE Park. We've slowly built that group over the years, and as anyone who's been to a Timbers game you now know, the Timbers Army has been kind of an icon to both the team and the City.
About two years ago when Merritt Paulson bought the team, there began to be some noise about the possibility of bringing a Major League Soccer team--it was always his vision. About eight months ago, nine months ago he officially launched the idea of making a formal bid in October--this was last summer. And a group of us decided that there needed to be a grassroots arm to this. There needed to be something that really spoke to the fans' voices, that we want Major League Soccer as well. When you looked around at the other bids out there, there wasn't the groundswell of support that we knew that we could generate here.
A guy named Mason Adair and I, and a few other folks got together and launched the MLStoPDX.com website. Our goal all along was to really make this about bringing in the fans, and the Timbers Army--but not just the Army, but youth soccer, local businesses...we were able to bring in as many folks as possible and that's where it got started and that's where I got involved.
My role--I'm an old political hack and was working previously for the state of Washington, was unfortunately laid off last summer, and opened up my own consulting shop. A really bad time to decide to go into business for yourself. So I was chronically underemployed this last fall and winter, and decided I had the time to do this, and something comes along once every...if ever. This is a once in a decade kind of opportunity--you have the owner, with the right bid, with the City Council interested--so I decided to make it a full time job for a couple of months.
I finally managed to catch up with Portland Commissioner Randy Leonard, the tip of the spear when it comes to the MLS deal that has apparently precipiated the awarding of an expansion franchise to Portland beginning in 2011. However, we pretended that the news of yesterday wasn't official, formal or obvious--and in any case, we talked mostly about other issues surrounding the process, including his ongoing debate with Ted Wheeler about City and County finance, why he thinks the Blazers did an about face, and what should go into the proposed entertainment district for the Rose Quarter.
The whole audio file of our 39-minute interview is available here, so that you can hear precisely the questions asked, and Leonard's full responses. Be warned that it's a 20MB .mp3 file, and as such may put a strain on your PC if you are using older equipment. But it's worth the full listen.
However, so that you don't HAVE to listen to it, I've transcribed readable versions of some of the questions and answers that yielded the most interesting parts of the conversation. I would call the transcript "close to verbatim;" while I've edited some things out for readability and length, the edits do not change the meaning of the responses, and once he gets into the meat of his answer his words are almost 100% as he said them. And of course if you're skeptical about that, listen to the audio for yourself.
So with that, let's hear what Randy had to say on the eve of what shapes up to be an historic announcement in Portland tomorrow!
-----
What do you think Chair Wheeler is expecting from the "new covenant" suggested to bring the County and Portland Public Schools more closely to the table in the Urban Renewal District (URD) discussions for the PGE Park area?
He was referencing a broader conversation he and I have had with reference to Measure A, a resolution adopted by the county in 1984, that was a document that reflected the division of responsibilities between the City of Portland and County of Multnomah. Basically what Resolution A said was the county will do jails, the county will do human services, and the city will do police, fire, parks, infrastructure services because up until 1984, there really was no core delineation who did what, who was responsible for what.
Since 1990 and the passage of Ballot Measure 5 the County has had diminishing resources, then they've had administrations in the White House who've cut various funding for human resource programs, aging programs--that money has diminished at the state, and the state has diminished it to the counties. The County has found itself in the position of having all these responsibilities stay and even increase as we've had a growing aging population and in some case a growing poverty population where the resources have diminished.
What Ted was talking about yes, I think let's talk about URAs and the impact on us, but also this broader discussion--should Multnomah County really be saddled with repairing all the bridges anymore? Shouldn't they be the City's responsibility? Should we be funding Hooper Detox anymore, when really primarily the people that are being served by that are Portland people? I know that's what he was saying, because he and I have had that discussion before.
"An important announcement about the future of professional soccer in the city of Portland” is scheduled for Friday morning.
The news is included in invitations that went out to members of the Portland business community Wednesday morning. It said the announcement would be made at the downtown Portland Hilton Hotel.
The invitations were made in the names of Merritt Paulson and Major League Soccer, Paulson is the Portland businessman seeking an MLS expansion team franchise. Neither party would publicly confirm the event to reporters who called seeking comment.
But Commission Randy Leonard's office confirms the press conference is scheduled with Paulson and MLS officials Friday morning. Leonard has been the most outspoken member of the City Council in support of bringing professional soccer to Portland. A number of City Hall sources say MLS Commissioner Don Garber will be at the event. [emph me]
So breaking (and apparently rushed), you need more than one hand to count the typos!
In an article posted at KGW.com about 1030AM and now updated with a rather mischevously revealing quote from Commissioner Randy Leonard, it would appear pretty damned likely that on the heels of the award of a franchise to Vancouver, BC today, Portland will indeed secure the second expansion team for 2011 play.
A news conference was reportedly scheduled by MLS and the Portland Timbers for Friday morning to make an announcement, according to several soccer message boards, including SoccerCityUSA.com and another website devoted to bringing a pro franchise to town.
According to reports, the press conference was scheduled for 9:30 a.m. Friday at the Portland Hilton between Timbers and MLS representatives.
Supporters hoped that if professional representatives were coming all the way to Portland, it must be to bring good news. "It looks like this is going to be the celebration we have all been waiting for," Portland resident Jeremy Wright wrote on one message board.
City Commissioner Randy Leonard, a supporter of the proposal, would not confirm nor deny the reports. He did speculate that league officials would "probably not travel to Portland to announce a franchise in Philadelphia."
You can almost hear the grin in Leonard's voice from that quotation. The article notes a bit wryly that Philly doesn't even have a bid on the table, which points either to Randy's need for city alliteration--or he's trying to tell you something in his non-confirm, non-denial.
I'm crossing lines with Commissioner Randy Leonard the last couple of days, getting his messages to late to respond to them, missing him by phone. I promise you I'll nail him down some time this week to answer questions on the MLS deal, particularly looking forward as the PGE Park Urban Renewal Area question looms, or in its place the search for alternate financing and how this affects Merritt Paulson's bid before MLS, or even Paulson's own desire to push forward with the gap unaddressed.
All of which is I suppose an ironic prelude to the point of this piece, which was to highlight how well Leonard is culling the reportage and opinion on the Council's approval of the agreement in principle last week, at his new website, http://www.commissionerleonard.typepad.com/..
Hey, that's off the venerated PortlandOnline gulag...er, centralized portal! Commissioner Randy doesn't mean to be impolite about his "employer supplied" website, but no sooner is "Welcome!" out of his virtual lips than you're urged not to hang out too long--look, Randy's got a new website, off the grid as it were! And while it's no marvel of flash animation and Randy-themed games or downloadable Randy Ringtone quotes (use that, Commissioner, and this is my record of the claim for 50%), it's pretty informative and transparent, even of reportage that's not necessarily flattering.
The most important document at the moment is undoubtedly the description of the terms of the agreement reached with Paulson, which you can read in detail here. For more of the info on the way the numbers were compiled, in that piece there's the link to the Task Force analysis as well.
But be sure to read through the links he provides; he captures a lot of the discussion from the big three papers plus the Business Journal, some of the TV coverage, etc. But you can get the gamut just from one source...The O. There's the laudatory (back page lead editorial), the critical (news analysis), the neutral but visceral (City Hall blog), and the sidebars, like Canzano's WTF about the sudden Blazers flip on the idea of a baseball park in the Quarter.
One thing that's original is a set of responses to some additional questioning from commenters at the site, written by Chief of Staff Ty Kovatch. And when I can stop Leonard's motor for 20-30 minutes and get him to answer even more questions (take a mile!), I'll report back. The FAQ-plus for the MLS deal is below the fold.
This, I suppose like the recent John Stewart reign of terror over Jim Cramer and CNBC, less about the person than the phenomenon and the pattern--and the item I'll point out is a minor one. But it speaks to the legion of misinformers working overtime on the proposed MLS deal, intentionally or otherwise. And no one is working harder to portray the current agreement as a public theft than annoying horsefly Jack Bogdanski.
That's not notable by itself; Bojack would complain if the City covered Bill Gates' hotel room the weekend he announced moving Microsoft from Redmond to Northeast Portland. And it's not really blogworthy to iterate the various mispresumptions that fly from the keyboards of the Ditto Crew that attends his faux-Finch pretensions at "not taking it anymore." They appear, they bounce about the echo chamber self-confirmingly, and they decay, to be chewed by the maggots as food for the next manufactured outrage.
But try to correct any of the more obvious flaws in muddle-headed thinking, and that discognition will get wiped off the map quick as a flash.
I'm going to post the headline and then backfill...
Moments ago, Dan Saltzman cast an Aye vote for the proposed financing of an MLS and new baseball stadium concept, but with a major condition: the proposal was first amended to REMOVE the $15 million projected to come from the construction of a new Urban Renewal Area around PGE Park. Commissioners Fish and Fritz had just voted No, and with expected Yeas by Randy Leonard and Mayor Adams, it was clear that everything came down to Dan.
His vote means that the proposal as amended is approved--which means there is a $15 million hole for the full funding. Will Merritt Paulson reject the deal on that basis? Will Council get it figured out in time, either with the URA or some other source? We'll see...
-----
Well, that was interesting! The portion of the City Council meeting dedicated to the fate of the MLS proposal took roughly from 10AM to 330PM, requiring the cancellation of other agenda items until tomorrow. (They almost adjourned without a vote, wanting to put THAT off until tomorrow as well, but Saltzman cannot be there and so that wasn't going to happen). I was able to listen along while working on other stuff and eating lunch, and can give an extended summary of the proceedings and the feelings of the individual Commissioners and other involved players. (If you want a quicker, dirtier, but currently available rundown, try Ryan White's liveblog. Wish I had the time/salary to do that!)
But let me offer an Executive Overview first: having to rely on the prospect of Dan Saltzman as your third vote for anything is a harrowing trial. And having to remain on pins and needles while wondering if he'll still vote No--even after having his HUGE and potentially thorny amendment to remove the most controversial funding source from the proposal accepted--is like waiting to be waterboarded.
Yet and still, it would appear that Saltzman's amendment has saved the day, because otherwise the whole proposal was going to fail. Because of the testimony from a number of sources including this morning's front page Oregonian story, the issue over creating a new URA around PGE Park quickly became the hot topic and the biggest stumbling block in the way of approval. An agreement to discuss the URA process, while more fully including those who feel they have been shut out of the discussions (ie, Multnomah County and Portland Public Schools), became the only way to preserve the rest of the deal.
So what will now happen is that Randy and Sam will work overtime to explain how the URA won't represent an immediate and sharp cut in basic services. From testimony, it seems the job will be hardest with Multno Chair Ted Wheeler and Commissioner Fritz, who also seemed worried about the counsel offered by the Blazers rep at the hearing, who confused everyone by saying a new Beavers stadium in the Rose Quarter would threaten his team's livelihood.
There are, however, twin dangers as I see it: time, and Paulson. Is there a realistic opportunity to hack through all the weeds over urban renewal, and reach an agreement within a week if necessary? Unsure. And it could only take longer than a week if Paulson agrees to take his proposal to MLS as approved by Council, with a sudden $15mil hole in the package. Would he cover the funds to make it happen? My strong guess is no. But will he just throw up his hands now when he is THIS close to victory? That's a tough one...
{hearing details below, once I'm able to collect my thoughts and get some more free time to write them up}
RSS Feed: http://www.loadedorygun.net/rss/rss2.xml
